Discussing "The 'Other Side' is not Dumb"
This entry is my comment regarding The "Other Side" is not Dumb.
That's
a really good article, and it does have some good points. I can relate
to some of it, like my tendency to have a knee-jerk judgement of people
who are big fans of "Duck Dynasty". Also, if I go someplace that has a
waiting room with Fox News playing on the TV, I probably won't go back. I
do read and watch LOTS of news, just not stuff like Fox. I also try to
ask questions of people who express opposing viewpoints, especially if
it's something I haven't encountered before, or if I think that asking
questions will get THEM to really examine their viewpoint. HOWEVER -
when discussing issues with conservative people, I find that in the
great majority of cases their facts really are just wrong. Often, what
it comes down to is that I end up arguing facts, while they are arguing
feelings.
There really is a completely different
approach to issues on the left and the right. Having outlets like Fox
"News", the Wall Street Journal, conservative talk radio, and some
conservative web sites has made the problem much worse, since they are
pumping out MIS-information on a continuous basis. When you dig down
deep enough, though, you usually find that "facts" don't carry nearly as
much weight on the right. Most Conservatives get their "news" from just
one or two official sources, but they get most of their "facts" from
other Conservatives. For most of them, what they've heard from other
people carries much more weight than any news source. Things stay in the
grapevine that have long been debunked officially. It's very
frustrating to try to discuss anything with people who don't even know
where they heard something, or why it may or may not be true. They just
KNOW it. They don't like to question what they believe they know. They
believe the first thing they've heard that fits into their worldview,
and they usually have a strong aversion to anything that questions that.
I
know I start to sound smug and dismissive of Conservative viewpoints,
but that's because often it's the same viewpoint I've heard a dozen
times, that I already know is based on some erroneous information that's
still floating around on the right. While I do change my mind about
issues all the time, based on new information, it's very difficult to
convince people of that who believe that facts are things that never
change. It's even more frustrating to try to discuss things with people
who only use "facts" to justify something they already believe, but who
aren't going to change what they believe whether the "facts" are true or
not.